View Full Version : Tuning In Lope
gpr
September 21st, 2009, 08:20 AM
This might seem like a crazy question, but i was wondering if you can actually tune an engine to make it lope. I love the sound and actually tuned my duramax to lope at an idle and it is kinda fun playing around with
I think it would be difficult on a gas engine as the only way i could see doing it was by varying the throttle position, so it would need ETC. Or you could have it idle rich and rev up then maybe somehow lean it out... I thought it would be kinda cool if i could make the engine lope with out changing the cam. Any ideas?
SSpdDmon
September 21st, 2009, 08:23 AM
Lope really has to do with valve events. I don't know if you could really alter a car to "lope" harder with out changing it mechanically. You might be able to drop the idle RPMs down some to try and achieve this...but, it'll probably stall more often.
LS1_Dragster
September 21st, 2009, 09:25 AM
I want just the opposite! I converted my 97 to a 0411 computer with custom OS and I cant stop it from loping! When I changed the cam several years ago I was sad it didn't lope but for some reason now it does.
So I guess the answer is yes, but I just don't know how...
Lee
WeathermanShawn
September 21st, 2009, 11:17 AM
I do not know if you can do this on your setup, but I experimented on 2002 LS1. I did the following:
1. Lowered idle to 650 Rpm's.
2. Lowered base spark to ~17-22 degrees.
3. Increased Desired airflow by 1-2 g/s (total 9 g/s).
Granted I have a cam with ~10 degrees of overlap, but, it did sound like a pro stock car. Personally, it was way too much for me. But, that is the only thing I can think of. I went back to a 800 Rpm, with ~22-24 degrees of base spark.
Would that work in your situation? It loped hard, but just did not sound right.
gpr
September 22nd, 2009, 05:43 AM
I'm messing around with a 2002 5.3L engine with an auto so i don't think I should have problems with it stalling. I will try the stuff you recommended. the engine is basically stock so i'm not sure if you can make a stock cam lope, but it would be fun if i could.
what does lowering the desired air flow do? i've never really understood what that table does as it seems if you have a set rpm idle point it should change whatever is needed to stay at that rpm.
LS1_Dragster
September 25th, 2009, 03:09 AM
I found your answer, by mistake. Turn on your EGR valve at idle! Your tune will go to crap and you'll need to adjust for it but it will make it lope! If your vehicle has an EGR, it seems newer ones may not.
Lee
WeathermanShawn
September 25th, 2009, 03:24 AM
GPR, go with whatever interests you. I can tell you from experience there is good lope, vs bad lope. What I mean by that is if you pick a reasonable idle, a lot of the 'chop' is from spark advance. Lower sounds choppy, higher sounds smoother. If a car sounds like it is dying..is that really lope?
As far as desired air, ironically raising it will make your idle sound louder. That is one of the best ways to get a cammed car to idle at a decent RPM. Lowering desired air (too much) it can make it sound very quiet. IMO raising desired air, a little less spark, and a slightly leaner AFR idle will get you to lope in a somewhat reasonable fashion. Granted having a decent cam with overlap is the best way!
limited cv8r
September 25th, 2009, 06:49 PM
A big lope really comes from old school carby, dissy tuning where you could only adjust so much and have to come to a compromise on idle speed, fueling and timing. With these newer injected, computer controlled motors, you have a lot more control of all of these parameters for fuel,spark ,airflow etc. Unless it is a really big cam, then a lopey idle is probably due to poor tuning. You "can" make these engines lope, but only because they are strugling to run properly on the tune in them.
Black02SS
September 26th, 2009, 11:28 AM
Quick way. Adjust the idle overspeed and underspeed timing tables. Take the overspeed and subtract another 10* and add 10* to the underspeed.
gpr
September 29th, 2009, 03:28 AM
Quick way. Adjust the idle overspeed and underspeed timing tables. Take the overspeed and subtract another 10* and add 10* to the underspeed.
This method worked very well and is very simple. Thanks for the help. I was just messing around to see if i could do it. I love the sound of old school big blocks with huge cams, and this makes the pickup sound a lot meaner, not that i really need it but when my camaro gets here i would like to do something like this.
I wouldn't think the constant spark timing changes would hurt anything if i left it this way, would you?
thanks again!
WeathermanShawn
September 29th, 2009, 03:54 AM
As long as it does not stall.
Remember every time you begin to stall your MAP goes up in value (less vacuum). Usually that equates to a much higher airmass/fueling value..not only can you stall, you go rich. Not great for the plugs if that is occurring.
If you have nothing to lose, go for it. I understand your enthusiasm. It will be a whole lot more fun with a decent sized cam with reasonable overlap in your next setup.
gpr
September 29th, 2009, 04:01 AM
One more question i about forgot. The second time I was running the engine i threw a code P0300 which is misfire detected. With this tune installed and it idling rough will i need to disable that code? I wouldn't think there is actually any miss fires, but the constant surging of rpm's is what set the code.
Do I live with this code being set, or is there a trick to getting rid of it? I would assume you run into the same problem with an engine that has a big cam and lopes hard at idle???
WeathermanShawn
September 29th, 2009, 04:46 AM
On my OS, there are two ways to handle misfires. One is Table B5601..you have all sots of Rpm's, detection temperature etc. The other are the DTC Processing Enablers and MIL Enablers.
Table B5601 takes care of me. It will not report misfires below 900 Rpm..my Idle Rpm is 800. Actually I left my DTC and MIL enablers stock. That way I can log any 'legitimate' misfires. No big deal. With a cam you get them all the time. I just have the software clear them out if I want to log misfires.
You might double-check with your setup and OS. It might actually be misfiring with that much spark variation. Perhaps someone will chime in on the best method to 'code-out' your situation. I am not sure what to advise you..since you have 'created' a lope without 'camming'...:grin:..
SSpdDmon
September 29th, 2009, 05:14 AM
This method worked very well and is very simple. Thanks for the help. I was just messing around to see if i could do it. I love the sound of old school big blocks with huge cams, and this makes the pickup sound a lot meaner, not that i really need it but when my camaro gets here i would like to do something like this.
I wouldn't think the constant spark timing changes would hurt anything if i left it this way, would you?
thanks again!
You should post a vid. I'm curious to what these changes sound like. :)
gpr
September 29th, 2009, 05:19 AM
I don't have a video but i have a recording off my phone of the exhaust. Its hard to hear but gives you some what of an idea. I want to mess with it more with different timing values and see if i can get it more erratic sounding.
weatherman, thanks for the tips. I don't have that table in my OS but found something like it and it should do the trick of not reporting misfires under a certain rpm. btw, i see you are from the DIA area? i'm about an hour away from you on I-76.
WeathermanShawn
September 29th, 2009, 05:25 AM
I don't have a video but i have a recording off my phone of the exhaust. Its hard to hear but gives you some what of an idea. I want to mess with it more with different timing values and see if i can get it more erratic sounding.
weatherman, thanks for the tips. I don't have that table in my OS but found something like it and it should do the trick of not reporting misfires under a certain rpm. btw, i see you are from the DIA area? i'm about an hour away from you on I-76.
Yes, got here 3 years ago. Met a few LS1'ers, but I work different hours, so kinda lost track of them. Occasionally I will use I-76 and a few country roads on some of tuning session. Honk if ya see me. Not many Hardtop Black Z-28 coupes around. Other than the chrome rims, I keep it subtle.
Where you from..or at?
gpr
September 29th, 2009, 05:32 AM
Born and raised east on i-76 in essentially the middle of no where. :) lots of tuning opportunities on open roads out here.
I tried attaching the sound clip i have off my phone but it won't let me attach that kind of file...
joecar
September 29th, 2009, 06:11 AM
Born and raised east on i-76 in essentially the middle of no where. :) lots of tuning opportunities on open roads out here.
I tried attaching the sound clip i have off my phone but it won't let me attach that kind of file...Can you create a compressed zip folder with that file...
WeathermanShawn
September 29th, 2009, 01:04 PM
Born and raised east on i-76 in essentially the middle of no where. :) lots of tuning opportunities on open roads out here.
I tried attaching the sound clip i have off my phone but it won't let me attach that kind of file...
I love Colorado..I take many rides out in the Prairie. I like going out by Last Chance, Co., It is actually pretty peaceful.
Keep trying to attach that file. It would be pretty interesting. If you need some help, let us know.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5 Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.